Rambam In-Depth: The Prohibition of Chatzi Shiur With Regard to Chametz
About this class
Rabbi Greenberg looks at the Rambam's ruling that eating less than a k'zayis, an olive's volume, of chametz is biblically forbidden, from the words "shall not be eaten," though only a k'zayis brings kares or a sin offering. The Kesef Mishneh, the Mishneh LaMelech and many others ask why a special verse is needed, when the Gemara in Yoma, as the Rambam rules, forbids half a measure of every prohibition. One answer is that a prohibition limited to Pesach rests on the person, not the food, but Yom Kippur is also time-bound. Another is that at the very end of Pesach a half-measure could no longer combine with more.
Finding these difficult, Rabbi Greenberg turns to the Ramban, who considers whether a half-measure belongs to each specific prohibition. The Rambam treats it as one general prohibition, so the verse makes half a measure of chametz part of the chametz prohibition itself, more stringent than a half-measure of other foods.
- The Rambam rules that eating less than a k'zayis of chametz is biblically forbidden, from the words "shall not be eaten," though kares and a sin offering apply only to a k'zayis.
- The Kesef Mishneh, the Mishneh LaMelech and many others ask why a separate verse is needed, since the Gemara in Yoma forbids half a measure of every prohibition and the Rambam rules so, and how the verse implies even a minute amount.
- One approach holds that a prohibition limited to a set time rests on the person rather than the food, so the half-measure rule would not apply to chametz, but the Gemara applies it to Yom Kippur; another holds that at the very end of Pesach a half-measure could no longer combine into a full measure, which Rabbi Greenberg also finds difficult.
- The Ramban in Yoma, discussing which forbidden food to give a person whose life is in danger, considers whether a half-measure of one prohibition is more stringent than a half-measure of another.
- Rabbi Greenberg explains that the Rambam treats a half-measure as one general prohibition, so the special verse makes a half-measure of chametz part of the chametz prohibition itself, more stringent than a half-measure of other forbidden foods.
The Prohibition of Chatzi Shiur With Regard the Chametz Rambam Hilchos Chametz Umatzah Chapter 1