Skip to content
Rambam In-Depth November 17, 2026

Rambam In-Depth: It Didn't Die From the Extra Weight. So Why Is He Liable?

Welcome to Rambam In-Depth: Hilchos Sechirus, Perek 4, Halacha 6 (Daled, Vav).

A man rents an animal, loads it with a little more than agreed, and the animal dies. If it could easily carry that weight, why should he have to pay?

The Rambam rules: someone who rents an animal to carry a specific weight and adds a thirtieth more is liable if the animal dies. Less than a thirtieth, he is patur. The Maggid Mishneh explains that it all goes by the agreement: the owner specified an amount, so going beyond it makes you pay, even if the animal could carry much more.

But the Ramban in Bava Metzia writes that as long as the load is within what the animal normally carries, the renter is not liable, because the animal most likely didn’t die from the extra weight. That sharpens the question on the Rambam: the renter isn’t a mazik, he didn’t cause the damage, so why should he pay? The Even HaAzel answers that the obligation isn’t the obligation of a mazik at all. It’s the obligation of a shomer. A shomer who is shalach yad, who uses what he’s guarding beyond his rights, becomes a gazlan, and a gazlan is liable even for an oness.

🔎 In this video we explore: • The Rambam’s rule of “a thirtieth”: when an extra load makes the renter liable • The Maggid Mishneh: why the agreement decides, not the animal’s strength • The Ramban’s view: no liability if the load is within normal capacity • If the extra weight didn’t kill the animal, why pay at all? • The Even HaAzel’s answer: liable as a shomer, not as a mazik • How a shomer who is shalach yad becomes a gazlan • Why a gazlan pays even for an oness, something beyond his control

💡 Key Insights:

  • Viewed as a mazik, the renter would be patur: the death was an oness.
  • Viewed as a shomer, he’s in a different category: by doing something unauthorized he became a gazlan.
  • A gazlan is liable for everything, even for what isn’t his fault.

📚 Sources discussed: Rambam, Hilchos Sechirus 4:6; Maggid Mishneh on the Rambam; Ramban, Bava Metzia 80 (daf pei); Even HaAzel on Hilchos Sechirus

▶️ YouTube: /rabbiheschelgreenberg 🎵 TikTok: /rabbi_greenberg 💼 LinkedIn: /rabbihgreenberg

In this class

  1. 0:00Welcome: Rambam, Hilchos Sechirus 4:6
  2. 0:07The case: renting an animal to carry a set weight
  3. 0:29Adding a thirtieth: chayav; less than that: patur
  4. 0:50The question: why is he liable?
  5. 0:56The Maggid Mishneh: it all goes by the agreement
  6. 1:25The Ramban (Bava Metzia 80): within normal capacity, not liable
  7. 1:54A question on the Rambam: he isn't a mazik
  8. 2:06The Even HaAzel: liable as a shomer, not as a mazik
  9. 2:24A shomer who is shalach yad becomes a gazlan
  10. 2:37Why an extra thirtieth makes him a gazlan
  11. 2:59Mitzad mazik vs. mitzad shomer: the bottom line