Is Transcendent Spirituality the Ultimate Goal?
About this class
Rabbi Greenberg asks whether transcendent spirituality is the ultimate goal, using the episode after the sin of the spies. After the ten spies brought back their report and the people wept, a group called the ma'pilim rose early, confessed that they had sinned, and set out for the mountain to enter the land. Moses told them it would not succeed and that God was not with them; they went anyway and were struck down by the Amalekites and Canaanites. Since they showed remorse, confession and resolve, why did they fail?
One answer is that the generation's sin was a lack of implicit trust in Moses, and by going against his word they repeated it. A deeper answer draws on the Alter Rebbe and the Chabad Rebbes: the spies were spiritual people who wanted to stay in the desert, free to study Torah. The ma'pilim saw that challenges bring greater spiritual growth, but still made their own spirituality the goal. The true goal, Rabbi Greenberg says, is to make the physical world a dwelling place for God through Torah study and above all through mitzvos.
- The ma'pilim showed remorse, confessed their sin and resolved to enter the land, yet they were defeated because they went against Moses' warning.
- One explanation is that the generation's sin was not trusting Moses implicitly, and going up despite his word showed that this had not been corrected.
- Following the Alter Rebbe and the Chabad Rebbes, the spies were spiritual people who preferred the desert, where all their needs were provided and they could devote themselves to Torah.
- The ma'pilim understood that a soul grows more amid the challenges of the material world, but they still treated their own spiritual growth as the goal.
- Rabbi Greenberg teaches that the purpose is to make this physical world a dwelling place for God, chiefly through observing mitzvos, which will bring the final Redemption through Mashiach.
Is Transcendent Spirituality the Ultimate Goal? Shlach