The Means to Effect A Neder | Rambam In-Depth
About this class
Rabbi Greenberg looks at the Rambam's rulings on vows made by comparison: one who declares produce forbidden "like a sacrifice" makes a valid vow, since a sacrifice becomes holy through a declaration, while "like pork" does not. Comparing to a sin offering works, since a nazir's sin offering comes about through his vow. Comparing to terumah, the portion given to a kohen, does not, since ordinary produce cannot become terumah by declaration. The Radvaz cites other reasons: the Rosh notes that untithed produce was already forbidden, and the Ran that terumah is forbidden only to non-kohanim.
The Keren Orah asks why comparing to the animal tithe works, when it too cannot be declared at will. The Kehillos Yaakov answers that calling the ninth animal the tenth makes it holy, and that the animal tithe belongs to the broader category of peace offerings, which can be vowed, while nothing can become terumah unless it is subject to terumah.
- The Rambam rules that a vow forbidding produce takes effect by comparison to something made forbidden through a vow, such as a sacrifice, but not to something like pork, which is forbidden regardless of any declaration.
- Comparison to a sin offering works, since some sin offerings, such as a nazir's, come about through a vow, but comparison to terumah does not, since ordinary produce cannot become terumah by declaration.
- The Radvaz cites the Rosh, who explains that untithed produce was already forbidden so the vow changes nothing, and the Ran, who notes that terumah is forbidden only to non-kohanim, so its prohibition comes from the Torah rather than from the vow.
- The Keren Orah asks why comparison to the animal tithe works, since an animal cannot be made a tithe at will, and answers with the reasons of the Rosh and the Ran, which the Rambam himself does not give.
- The Kehillos Yaakov answers that calling the ninth or eleventh animal the tenth makes it holy, and that the animal tithe belongs to the broader category of peace offerings, which can be vowed, while nothing can become terumah unless it is subject to the laws of terumah.