Skip to content
Rambam In-Depth May 31, 2022 9 min

Rambam's Obsession With the Negation of Idolatry

About this class

Rambam, Mishneh Torah: Hilchos Avodah Zarah, chapter 4

Rabbi Greenberg looks at the Rambam's ruling that one who derives even the slightest benefit from an ir hanidachas, a city whose inhabitants mostly worshipped idols and whose property must all be destroyed, receives lashes, based on the verse "nothing of the banned property shall cling to your hand." The Chikrei Lev asks why the Gemara in Shevuos, challenging the sages' view that the Torah never forbids a minuscule amount, does not cite this case.

Based on a discourse of the Rebbe, Rabbi Greenberg distinguishes prohibitions in which a tiny amount is itself the measure, such as carrying a significant spice on Shabbos, from idolatry, for which there is no measure at all, since the Torah wants it entirely gone. He adds that even the ashes of idolatry, and unusual benefit from it, are forbidden, and concludes that the Rambam explains many mitzvos as distancing from idolatry, his life's aim being a world filled with knowledge of God.

  • The Rambam rules that one who derives even the slightest benefit from the property of an ir hanidachas receives lashes, based on the verse "nothing of the banned property shall cling to your hand."
  • The Chikrei Lev asks why the Gemara in Shevuos, which challenges with many examples the sages' claim that the Torah nowhere forbids a minuscule amount, does not cite the ir hanidachas.
  • Based on a discourse of the Rebbe on the Rambam's laws of the Beis HaBechirah, Rabbi Greenberg distinguishes prohibitions in which a minuscule amount is itself the measure, such as carrying a spice or perfume on Shabbos, from idolatry, where there is no measure at all because the Torah wants nothing of it to remain.
  • He adds that the ashes of a burned forbidden item are normally permitted, and benefit in an unnatural way is normally not forbidden, but idolatry is an exception in both cases.
  • Rabbi Greenberg notes that the Rambam explains many mitzvos, such as shatnez, meat and milk and the laws of the sidelocks and beard, as distancing from idolatry, which he devoted his life to uprooting so as to bring the time when the world will be filled with the knowledge of God.

Summary prepared from the class recording.

Rambam In-Depth: Laws of Avodah Zarah Chapter 4

Part of the series Rambam In-Depth