The Requirement of Consent in Kiddushin
About this class
Rabbi Greenberg discusses the Rambam's ruling that a woman can be betrothed only with her consent. The Gemara in Bava Basra holds that a sale made under duress is valid when the seller is paid, and for betrothal it explains the invalidity as a rabbinic annulment of a marriage done improperly. The Rambam omits this, implying the marriage is invalid by Torah law. The Chasam Sofer explains that a forbidden act has no effect, and forcing a woman to marry violates the prohibition against coveting.
Drawing on many recent authorities, Rabbi Greenberg offers another approach, starting from two different sources Rashi gives for the need for consent. Betrothal has two aspects: a kinyan binding her to her husband, which needs only ordinary consent, and her complete dedication to him, which forbids her to all others and requires full willingness. A coerced marriage lacks the second aspect, which the Rambam treats as an inherent flaw.
- The Rambam rules that a woman cannot be betrothed against her will, without citing the Gemara's explanation that the Sages annulled such a marriage because the man acted improperly.
- The Chasam Sofer explains that the marriage fails by Torah law because forcing a woman to marry violates the prohibition against coveting, and an act the Torah forbids has no effect.
- Rashi gives two sources for the need for consent: the consent required of anyone transferring what is his, and the verse describing a woman going to marry another man; the Rebbe explains that Rashi on the Torah derives it instead from Rivkah being asked, since by its plain meaning that verse does not prove consent.
- Following the Ran's view that a woman makes herself wholly her husband's, betrothal involves both a kinyan, based on the money given, and her complete dedication, effected by the betrothal declaration, which forbids her to all others; the first needs only the consent that suffices in a coerced sale, the second requires full willingness.
- A coerced marriage lacks this second aspect, unlike a merely forbidden marriage such as a kohen marrying a divorcee, which explains why the Sages annulled it and why the Rambam treats it as inherently flawed.
Rambam In-Depth: Laws of Ishus Chapter 4