Skip to content
Video class July 19, 2022 16 min

The Two Opinions of Our Sages Concerning the Solar Year Rambam

About this class

Rambam, Mishneh Torah: Hilchos Kiddush HaChodesh, chapter 9

Rabbi Greenberg looks at the Rambam's citation of two views of the solar year: 365 and a quarter days, the view of Shmuel, and slightly less, the view of Rav Ada. For the leap year the Rambam relies on Rav Ada's figure as more accurate; the Rebbe infers that both are true. In a talk on Birkas HaChamah, the blessing over the sun every 28 years, the Rebbe asks why that blessing and the season for requesting rain follow Shmuel, when only Rav Ada's figure keeps Pesach in the spring.

The Rebbe compares the new moon, where the court's declaration fixes the true molad, and explains that physical events below do not always align with the higher reality. Drawing on the view that the world was conceived in Nissan and created in Tishrei, he explains that the seasons follow the higher reality, while for the Pesach offering below and above must match, so Rav Ada is followed.

  • The Rambam cites two views of the solar year, 365 and a quarter days according to Shmuel and slightly less according to Rav Ada, and for the leap year relies on Rav Ada's figure as more accurate, from which the Rebbe infers that both are true.
  • In a talk on the blessing over the sun every 28 years, the Rebbe asks why that blessing and the season for requesting rain follow Shmuel, when only Rav Ada's figure ensures that Pesach always falls in the spring.
  • The Rebbe compares the new moon, where the court's declaration determines the true molad even when it differs from the physical one, and explains that physical events below are not always aligned with the higher reality.
  • Since the seasons are physical and the blessing requires seeing the sun, the Rebbe draws on the teaching that the world was conceived in Nissan and created in Tishrei to explain that the seasons follow a higher reality, while for the Pesach offering what happens below must match what is above, so Rav Ada is followed.
  • Rabbi Greenberg cites the explanation that false witnesses are not punished if the accused was executed, since the court's allowing it shows he was guilty in a higher reality, and asks whether a similar defense of Rabbeinu Tam's view of sunset fits the Rebbe's approach.

Summary prepared from the class recording.

Rambam In-Depth: Laws of Kiddush Hachodesh Chapter 9

In this class

  1. 0:00The two opinions on solar year
  2. 2:13Rambam's calendar calculation
  3. 4:42Spiritual versus physical reality
  4. 7:30Applying the spiritual reality concept
  5. 10:40Witness testimony and Rabbeinu Tam
  6. 13:35Order of matzah and maror

Part of the series Rambam In-Depth