The 1,000-Year-Old Jewish Answer to 'Why Do Bad Things Happen to Good People'
Welcome to a transformative journey through one of the most remarkable periods in Jewish intellectual history — the Medieval Golden Age of Wisdom. In a world where Islamic philosophy, Greek rationalism, and internal Jewish schism all challenged the foundations of faith simultaneously, three extraordinary rabbinic minds rose to meet every challenge with brilliance, depth, and enduring relevance. Whether you’ve wrestled with questions of faith and reason, felt spiritually hollow despite religious observance, or wondered what makes the Jewish people uniquely significant in history, this class will open doors you didn’t even know existed. Join our growing community of seekers, scholars, and students as we explore the wisdom that has guided Jewish thought for a millennium — and discover why it speaks more powerfully than ever to our modern world.
This class is the third in our “Revolutions of the Soul” series, exploring the pivotal moments that shaped Jewish thought across history. The Medieval Intellectual Revolution (9th–12th centuries) was ignited when Jewish communities in Babylonia and then Spain encountered Greek philosophy through Islamic translations — and were suddenly confronted with questions their ancestors never had to answer. From the Karaite schism that threatened to permanently divide the Jewish people, to the challenge of reconciling Torah with Aristotle, to the internal crisis of Jews who performed every mitzvah but lost their soul — the sages of this era met every challenge with depth and courage. Rabbi Saadia Gaon proved Judaism was rationally coherent. Bachya ibn Paquda turned the lens inward to the life of the heart. Yehuda Halevi rejected pure philosophy in favor of national revelation and the centrality of Israel. And Maimonides synthesized it all in a philosophical system that shaped Christian and Islamic thought as well. These aren’t distant historical figures. Their questions are your questions.
📖 Primary Sources & References:
- Saadia Gaon, Emunot V’Deot (Book of Beliefs & Opinions), 933 CE — first systematic Jewish philosophy
- Bachya ibn Paquda, Chovot HaLevavot (Duties of the Heart), ~1080 CE
- Yehuda Halevi, Kuzari, ~1140 CE
- Maimonides, Mishneh Torah & Moreh Nevuchim (Guide for the Perplexed), 12th century
- Ecclesiastes 3:11 — “He made everything beautiful in its time”
- Zohar — primary work of Kabbalah (on reincarnation)
In this class
- 0:00Introduction — "He Made Everything Beautiful in Its Time"
- 2:30Synchronicity — When Ideas Are Ready to Emerge
- 5:00The Story of Rabbi Yosef Karo and His Angel
- 8:00Historical Background: Babylonia, Islam & the Translation Movement
- 13:00The Karaite Schism — Anan ben David's Break from the Oral Torah
- 17:00Rabbi Saadia Gaon — Biography & Rise to Leadership
- 22:00The Calendar Dispute That Almost Split the Jewish People
- 26:00Saadia's Magnum Opus: Emunot V'Deot (Beliefs & Opinions)
- 30:00Saadia's Three Proofs for Creation: Composition, Temporality & Finitude
- 35:00Saadia on God's Unity and Negative Anthropomorphism
- 38:00Saadia's Four Explanations for the Suffering of the Righteous
- 43:00Saadia on Resurrection of the Dead vs. Reincarnation
- 46:00Bachya ibn Paquda — Introduction & Duties of the Heart
- 50:00The Ten Gates: Unity, Reflection, Service & Trust
- 54:00The Innkeeper Story — What Real Trust in God Looks Like
- 58:00Yehuda Halevi — Poet, Physician & Champion of Israel
- 1:01:00The Kuzari — The King of the Khazars Meets the Jewish Sage
- 1:04:00"My Heart Is in the East" — Israel as Spiritual Center
- 1:05:30Maimonides — Negative Theology & the Rational Mitzvah
- 1:06:30Q&A — Can Prophecy Happen Outside of Israel?