Rambam In-Depth I Trumah: Thought vs. Action
About this class
Rabbi Greenberg looks at the Rambam's ruling that one who separates terumah in his thoughts, without saying a word, has made valid terumah, since the Torah's word "reckoned" teaches that thought alone suffices. Commentators debate whether "separates" means he set the portion aside physically and only designated it in thought, or whether thought alone is enough, as the end of the ruling suggests.
Rabbi Greenberg brings Rashi's explanation of the Talmud's phrase that one "puts his eyes" on one side and eats from the other: he focuses on where he will separate. This may work for Rashi because he holds the terumah is already present within tevel (untithed produce), but the Talmud uses that phrase only in two special cases. The Rambam, he suggests, requires a definite intent to designate, though no action or speech. The Rebbe's father held the separation must be physical, while the Rebbe held thought alone suffices, a dispute tied to whether such terumah becomes holy.
- The Rambam rules that terumah separated in thought alone, without speech, is valid, since the Torah's word 'reckoned' teaches that thought suffices.
- Some commentators understand that the produce must be physically separated and only the designation may be in thought, while others read the Rambam as requiring thought alone.
- Rashi explains the Talmud's phrase that one 'puts his eyes' on one side as focusing on where he will separate, which may suffice for Rashi because he holds the terumah is already within the untithed produce.
- Since the Talmud uses that phrase only regarding mixtures of terumah and demai (produce of doubtful tithing), Rabbi Greenberg suggests the Rambam requires a definite intent to designate the portion now, though without any action or speech.
- The Rebbe's father held that the Rambam requires physical separation, while the Rebbe held that thought alone suffices, a dispute tied to whether terumah separated in thought becomes holy or only removes the tevel status.
Dive deep into the fascinating world of Rambam’s teachings on trumah in this eye-opening video. Uncover the hidden meanings behind his cryptic words and explore the debate surrounding his controversial ideas. Learn how mere thoughts can create trumah according to Rambam, and discover the intricate interpretations of his work by various scholars. This video breaks down complex Talmudic concepts, making them accessible to all. Whether you’re a religious scholar or simply curious about ancient wisdom, this exploration of Rambam’s trumah theory will leave you questioning everything you thought you knew. Join us on this intellectual journey and expand your understanding of Jewish law and philosophy. Don’t miss out on this mind-bending revelation – watch now and join the discussion!