Skip to content
Rambam In-Depth July 17, 2024 9 min

Rambam In-Depth I Nazirite Mystery: Jews vs. Non-Jews

About this class

Rambam, Mishneh Torah: Hilchos Nezirus

Rabbi Greenberg looks at the Rambam's ruling that a non-Jew is not subject to the laws of nezirus (the Nazirite vow), since the Torah addresses the children of Israel. Rashi explains that a non-Jew who vows to be a nazir may still shave, drink wine and become impure from the dead, while Tosafos holds that he is only excluded from the nazir's offerings. The Rebbe, like the Keren Orah, asks why a verse is needed to exempt him from restrictions he was never commanded, and why the Rambam does not mention them.

The Rebbe explains that although keeping one's word is not among the seven Noahide laws, non-Jews are bound by duties that logic compels, as the curse of mi shepara shows. So a non-Jew who vows "I am a nazir" is not bound, but one who specifies abstaining from wine or cutting his hair must keep it, which is why the Rambam states no unconditional exemption.

  • The Rambam rules that a non-Jew is not subject to the laws of nezirus, since the Torah addresses the children of Israel.
  • Rashi explains that a non-Jew's vow to be a nazir has no effect, so he may shave, drink wine and become impure from the dead, while Tosafos understands that he is only excluded from the nazir's offerings, since non-Jews may otherwise bring offerings.
  • The Rebbe, like the Keren Orah, asks why a verse is needed to exempt a non-Jew from restrictions he was never commanded, and why the Rambam does not say that he may drink wine or cut his hair.
  • Keeping one's word is not among the seven Noahide laws, but the Rebbe explains that it is an obligation compelled by logic, which binds non-Jews as well, as shown by the curse of mi shepara, which compares one who breaks his word to the generations of the Flood and the Tower of Babel.
  • A non-Jew who simply vows to be a nazir, invoking the Torah's institution, is not bound, but one who vows specifically to abstain from wine or not to cut his hair must keep it, so the Rambam cannot state the exemption unconditionally.

Summary prepared from the class recording.

Discover the hidden depths of Rambam’s teachings on non-Jewish Nazirites in this mind-blowing exploration of ancient Jewish law. Uncover the fascinating intersection of logic, divine commandments, and universal morality that shaped our understanding of vows and obligations. This video delves into the complexities of Talmudic discourse, offering insights that will challenge your perception of religious law and human nature. Perfect for history buffs, philosophy enthusiasts, and anyone curious about the foundations of modern ethics. Don’t miss this eye-opening journey through time and wisdom!

In this class

  1. 0:00Introduction to Rambam's Ruling
  2. 0:31The Non-Jew and Nazirite Laws
  3. 1:22Questioning Rashi's Interpretation
  4. 2:51Universal Morality and Vows
  5. 5:03Logical Imperatives vs. Biblical Commands
  6. 7:00Practical Differences in Vow Observance

Part of the series Rambam In-Depth