Skip to content
Rambam In-Depth March 12, 2024 6 min

Rambam In-Depth I False Witness Perplexity

About this class

Rabbi Greenberg looks at the Rambam's ruling that one who hires false witnesses against another is exempt under human law but liable under the laws of Heaven, as is a witness who withholds testimony. He asks whether this means a real debt that the court cannot collect, or only accountability to God that paying would remove. A work on the laws of witnesses connects this to a dispute: the Maharam Mintz permits the court to use public verbal pressure to make him pay, implying a debt, while the Maharshal forbids even that. They are consistent in a second dispute, whether the injured party may keep property he seizes.

One authority limits the liability to actually hiring witnesses, not merely asking someone to lie as a favor. Regarding the Talmud's teaching that one who tells another to kill is liable in Heaven, the explanation given is that hiring creates a financial obligation, while a mere request creates only a moral one.

  • The Rambam rules that one who hires false witnesses against another, and a witness who withholds testimony, are exempt under human law but liable under the laws of Heaven.
  • Rabbi Greenberg asks whether this liability is a real financial debt that the court cannot collect, or only accountability to God that paying would remove.
  • The Maharam Mintz allows the court to pressure him verbally, such as by a public announcement in the synagogue, implying a real debt, while the Maharshal forbids even verbal pressure, implying there is none.
  • They are consistent in another dispute: the Maharam Mintz lets the injured party keep property he seized from the one who hired the witnesses, while the Maharshal does not.
  • One authority holds there is no liability for merely asking someone to testify falsely without payment, explaining that hiring creates a financial obligation, while the Talmud's teaching that one who tells another to kill is liable in Heaven refers to moral liability.

Summary prepared from the class recording.

Delve into the captivating world of Jewish law and unravel the intricate web surrounding the liability of those who hire or encourage false witnesses. In this thought-provoking exploration, we dive deep into the teachings of the revered Rambam (Maimonides) and the intense debate that ensued among early scholars. Discover the profound implications of such actions and the fierce discourse between the Maharal Mints and the Rambam Mabit on whether there exists a mere moral obligation or a financial liability that cannot be enforced by the courts. Prepare to be enlightened as we navigate the nuances of legal and moral accountability, verbal coercion, confiscation of property, and the practical differences that shape our understanding of this complex issue. Join us on a journey through ancient wisdom, legal loopholes, and the ethical dilemmas that arise when deception infiltrates the pursuit of justice. This captivating video promises to challenge your perspectives and leave you in awe of the profound insights offered by the Rambam and the scholarly giants who grappled with this perplexing conundrum. The Rambam’s Teachings on False Witnesses 00:00 This introductory chapter sets the stage by exploring the Rambam’s teachings on the liability of hiring false witnesses and the consequences that follow. The Scholarly Debate: Maharal Mints vs. Rambam Mabit 01:31 This chapter delves into the intense discourse between the Maharal Mints and the Rambam Mabit, examining their contrasting views on whether there is a financial obligation or merely a moral obligation in cases of hiring false witnesses. Practical Implications: Seizing Property and Legal Loopholes 04:08 This chapter explores the practical implications of the scholarly debate, addressing whether the victim can legally seize the perpetrator’s property as compensation and potential legal loopholes. Hired Witnesses vs. Encouraged Testimony: The Rambam’s Distinction 04:54 This chapter examines the Rambam’s stance on the crucial distinction between hiring false witnesses and merely encouraging someone to testify falsely, and the associated liabilities and consequences. Concluding Wisdom: The Rambam’s Profound Insights 06:14 The final chapter provides additional profound insights from the Rambam and concluding remarks on the complexities and ethical dilemmas surrounding this topic.

In this class

  1. 0:00The Rambam's Teachings on False Witnesses
  2. 1:31The Scholarly Debate: Maharal Mints vs. Rambam Mabit
  3. 4:08Practical Implications: Seizing Property and Legal Loopholes
  4. 4:54Hired Witnesses vs. Encouraged Testimony: The Rambam's Distinction
  5. 6:14Concluding Wisdom: The Rambam's Profound Insights

Part of the series Rambam In-Depth