Skip to content
Rambam In-Depth October 20, 2025 4 min

Rambam In-Depth: Can You Use Plastic Cups for Kiddush? The Answer Will SHOCK You!

About this class

Rambam, Mishneh Torah: Hilchos Keilim 5:7

Rabbi Greenberg looks at the Rambam's ruling that an animal horn used once and thrown away is not susceptible to impurity, and whether this shows that a disposable cup is not a proper vessel for Kiddush or washing the hands, as the Shraga HaMeir and others conclude. Others reject the proof, since the Rambam rules earlier that any vessel that can hold something is susceptible, even one made of paper or a pomegranate shell by children, excluding only something that will rot.

Rabbi Greenberg resolves the contradiction: a horn does not look like a vessel and becomes one only through the owner's intent, so if he means to discard it, it never gains that status, while a paper cup has the shape of a vessel and is inherently one. By this analysis, which he notes is not a halachic ruling, a reusable plastic cup is a vessel and may be used for Kiddush and washing.

  • The Rambam rules that an animal horn used once and then discarded is not susceptible to impurity, and some, including the Shraga HaMeir, infer that a disposable cup may not be used for Kiddush or washing the hands.
  • Others reject this inference, since the Rambam rules elsewhere that any vessel that can hold something is susceptible, even one made of paper or a pomegranate shell by children, unless it will rot, like a dried gourd.
  • Rabbi Greenberg explains that a horn does not look like a vessel and becomes one only by the owner's designation, so if he plans to discard it after one use, it is not a vessel.
  • A paper cup or a pomegranate-shell cup has the shape of a vessel and is inherently one, regardless of the owner's plans.
  • According to this analysis, which he stresses is not a halachic ruling, a plastic cup that could last beyond one use is a vessel and may be used for Kiddush and for washing before bread.

Summary prepared from the class recording.

🌟 Every Week in Shul, You Face This Question - Now Get The Definitive Answer 🌟

Have you ever stood at the Kiddush table wondering whether it’s okay to use those plastic disposable cups for making Kiddush? You’re not alone. This seemingly simple question sparked major halachic debates and reveals profound insights into how Jewish law views objects, intention, and ritual purity. In this fascinating deep dive, we explore how the Rambam’s discussion of an animal horn leads us through an intricate legal analysis that ultimately validates your Friday night convenience while teaching us revolutionary concepts about how human intention shapes reality itself. This isn’t just about plastic cups - it’s about understanding the brilliant methodology the Rambam uses to resolve apparent contradictions and extract practical guidance from ancient legal principles.

🧠 In this comprehensive exploration, we uncover:

  • Why a disposable animal horn isn’t susceptible to ritual impurity
  • The shocking contradiction in Rambam’s own writings about vessels
  • How children’s toy cups made from pomegranate shells reveal deep legal principles
  • The revolutionary distinction between inherent keili status and designated keili status
  • Why your plastic cup is actually MORE valid than you thought
  • The Tzitz Eliezer’s brilliant resolution of the apparent contradiction
  • Practical applications for every Shabbat, Yom Tov, and ritual hand-washing

📖 Primary Sources Referenced:

  • Rambam Hilchot Keilim 5:7 - The horn that’s used once and discarded
  • Rambam Hilchot Keilim 2:1 - All vessels (even paper) are susceptible to tumah
  • *Shoel U’Meishiv - Early strict position on disposable cups
  • She’eilot U’Teshuvot Shraga HaMeir - Prohibition of disposable cups for Kiddush
  • Tzitz Eliezer - Brilliant resolution of the contradiction
  • Contemporary Poskim - Modern application to plastic cups

In this class

  1. 0:00Welcome and the Practical Question: Disposable Cups for Kiddush
  2. 0:28Rambam's Law: The Disposable Horn That Isn't Susceptible to Tumah
  3. 0:49The Practical Problem: What About Plastic Cups at Shul?
  4. 1:12The Strict Ruling: Shraga HaMeir and the Prohibition
  5. 1:37The Contradiction: Rambam's Earlier Statement About All Vessels
  6. 2:14The Exception: When Objects Don't Acquire Keili Status
  7. 2:31The Resolution: Two Types of Keilim Explained
  8. 2:58Animal Horns: Objects That Need Human Designation
  9. 3:29Paper Cups and Pomegranate Shells: Objects with Inherent Shape
  10. 3:48The Final Ruling: Why Plastic Cups ARE Permissible
  11. 4:09Summary and Practical Applications

Part of the series Rambam In-Depth