Skip to content
Relationships January 5, 2022 18 min

From Oy to Ah

About this class

Rabbi Greenberg explains how to hold on to joy beneath suffering, starting from the Torah's wording that Jacob went "to Charan" with a suffix rather than the usual prefix. A Sephardic commentator explains that the suffix means Jacob went into the very core of Charan, a name meaning wrath, in order to elevate it and free its sparks of holiness. Charan is also nearly identical to rinah, joy: the letters differ only by a hairbreadth, and adding the suffix to Charan spells rinah, so anger and exile ultimately lead to joy.

Rather than optimism or pessimism, Rabbi Greenberg proposes a third perspective. The Alter Rebbe teaches in Tanya that pain is real and must be felt, yet it comes from a higher, hidden level of the divine that will be revealed in the messianic age. This is how Hillel knew the crying he heard was not from his house: his family could see the hidden good. A Chassid in great pain would turn his groan into an expression of delight, from "oy" to "ah." Still, we must cry out to God to end the exile.

  • The suffix in "to Charan" indicates that Jacob went fully into the place in order to elevate it and liberate its sparks of holiness.
  • Charan, meaning wrath, and rinah, meaning joy, differ by a hairbreadth, showing that the negative leads to joy.
  • The Alter Rebbe explains that exile's purpose of gaining converts also means absorbing sparks of holiness from negative places.
  • Pain must be felt and not explained away, yet beneath it lies a hidden, higher divine level that will be revealed in the messianic age.
  • The Rebbe urged Jews to cry out to God asking how much longer the exile will last, followed by joyous faith that redemption is imminent.

Summary prepared from the class recording.

Beneath the surface of our suffering and pain is something positive. We must demand that G-d reveal to us to us the “ah-ha” moment.

In this class

  1. 0:00Jacob flees from Esau
  2. 1:04The nuance of 'Kharana'
  3. 3:02Elevating sparks of holiness
  4. 5:55From anger to joy
  5. 8:58Pessimism vs optimism
  6. 11:03Reconciling pain and faith
  7. 16:17Hope for redemption

Part of the series Life Skills