An Eye for an Eye
About this class
Rabbi Greenberg explains why the Torah says "an eye for an eye" when the oral tradition always understood it as monetary compensation. Citing Rabbi Yosef Zevin, based on Maimonides, he teaches that no payment can truly cover an eye; the offender is really paying a ransom for his own eye, which in truth he deserved to lose. This forces him to personalize the injury and empathize with his victim, and that empathy is what brings atonement.
- The oral tradition passed down from Moses never read "an eye for an eye" literally, and the Talmud shows from the text that it means compensation.
- Following Rabbi Yosef Zevin, based on Maimonides, the payment is a ransom for the offender's own eye, which he deserved to lose.
- The Torah's wording forces the offender to imagine the injury as his own, teaching empathy as the path to atonement.
Next time you find yourself in conflict, put yourself in the other person’s shoes. Empathy is the only road to peace. Do you agree?