It's Not Your Business
About this class
Rabbi Greenberg explains why the consequences of helping another person are not our business, through Jacob's meeting with his brother Esau. Rashi notes that Jacob brought his wives and eleven sons but hid his daughter Dinah in a box, fearing Esau would want to marry her, and that Jacob was punished for it. Rabbi Greenberg asks why, since any father would protect his daughter, and cites a disciple of the Baal Shem Tov who says Jacob feared Dinah would change Esau for the better.
Rabbi Greenberg suggests that Jacob, recalling the prophecy that when one brother rises the other falls, worried that a spiritually elevated Esau would undermine his own mission to raise a nation committed to the Torah. Yet that is God's concern, not ours, as the prophet Isaiah told King Hezekiah, who refused to marry because he foresaw an evil son. Our task is to bring every Jew closer to God, taking precautions but never shirking the responsibility, and that love will bring the redemption.
- Rashi says Jacob hid Dinah in a box so Esau would not see her, and was punished for it.
- A disciple of the Baal Shem Tov explains that Jacob feared Dinah would rehabilitate Esau, not that Esau would harm her.
- Rabbi Greenberg suggests Jacob worried that if Esau rose spiritually he himself would fall, endangering his mission to found the Jewish nation.
- The Talmud relates that the prophet Isaiah scolded King Hezekiah for refusing to marry because he foresaw an evil son, since that was God's business.
- We must reach out to every Jew with love, taking precautions but not shirking the responsibility out of fear of side effects.
Why did Jacob hide his daughter Dinah from Esau, and why was he punished for it? Our task is to bring every Jew closer to God with love; the consequences of helping another person are God’s business, not ours.