Skip to content
Video class July 1, 2026 48 min

Why Holy People Sometimes Act Like Fools

About this class

Pirkei Avos 3:12

Rabbi Greenberg explains Pirkei Avos 3:12, in which Rabbi Yishmael teaches how to relate to three kinds of people: be yielding to a superior, be pleasant to the young, and receive every person with joy. He first discusses the name Yishmael, common among the sages because Abraham's son Ishmael repented at the end of his life. Toward a leader, one should accept authority easily and even make oneself "light," as King David danced before the Ark despite Michal's protest; acting the fool before something holy is a positive kind of folly, and the Rebbe gave the same answer when criticized for singing and whistling at his gatherings. Joshua succeeded Moses, Rabbi Greenberg says, because he never left Moses' tent, and the Talmud says serving Torah scholars is greater than learning from them.

Toward the young one should be pleasant without deferring to them, and the Talmud defines an elder by acquired wisdom, not age alone. He cites Rabbi Yishmael's own submission to the sages after adjusting a lamp on Shabbos, and Rabbi Yehoshua's deference to Rabban Gamliel over the date of Yom Kippur. Receiving everyone with joy goes beyond Shammai's "pleasant face" to real inner happiness. Read inwardly, the Mishnah says to obey the intellect, be gentle with the emotions, and embrace the body with joy, as the Baal Shem Tov's parable of a captive who got his guards drunk so he could dance illustrates.

  • Before a superior or something holy, a person should make himself small, even foolish, as King David did when he danced before the Ark.
  • Joshua became Moses' successor because he never left Moses' tent and learned from living with him, not only from his teachings.
  • One should be pleasant to the young without deferring to them, and true seniority is measured by acquired wisdom, not age alone.
  • Shammai taught greeting everyone with a pleasant face, but Rabbi Yishmael asks for genuine inner joy.
  • Applied within a person, the Mishnah means submitting to the intellect, respecting the emotions, and treating the body as a partner in serving God.

Summary prepared from the class recording.

Welcome to Ethics of the Fathers (Pirkei Avot): Chapter 3, Mishna 12

Why would King David dance and jump around in public like a fool — and why does Rabbi Yishmael say that’s exactly what you should do in the presence of something greater than yourself?

In this week’s class, Rabbi Heschel Greenberg unpacks a teaching from Rabbi Yishmael that lays out three completely different postures for how to treat people: be submissive to someone above you, be pleasant to someone below you, and greet every single person with genuine joy.

The most surprising part is what “being submissive” (kal, “light”) really means — not just polite deference, but a willingness to look foolish in the presence of something greater than yourself. Rabbi Greenberg traces that idea through King David dancing before the Ark, a Hasidic rebbe whistling and dancing mid-discourse, and a Talmudic story about a rabbi who juggled at a wedding and was buried in a grave surrounded by holy fire. He also digs into why Rabbi Yishmael’s own name eventually disappeared from Jewish naming custom, what it really means to learn from a teacher by living close to them, and why Chassidic teaching insists your body and your emotions are full participants in holiness rather than obstacles to it.

🔎 In this video we explore:

  • Why a rabbi’s own name can fall out of use — and what “Yishmael” actually means
  • The real difference between how you owe respect to a superior, a peer, and someone younger or junior to you
  • Why King David danced “like a fool” before the Ark, and why his wife Michal was wrong to shame him for it
  • What it means that Elisha “poured water” for Elijah — and why the Talmud says that’s greater than being his student
  • Why Joshua succeeded Moses over more scholarly, senior candidates — and the one flaw hidden inside his humility
  • The Hebrew wordplay behind zaken (“elder”) that redefines what real seniority actually means
  • Why the Baal Shem Tov’s followers got a prison guard drunk — and what it teaches about joy and the body

💡 Key Insights:

  • Respect isn’t one-size-fits-all — the Torah gives different postures for how to relate to superiors, equals, and those younger or junior to you.
  • “Holy foolishness” — dropping your dignity in the presence of something greater than yourself — is treated as a real spiritual value, not an embarrassment.
  • The deepest way to learn from a teacher isn’t hearing their lectures, it’s living close enough to absorb how they actually live.
  • Judaism doesn’t ask you to suppress your emotions or shame your body — it asks your mind to lead, your emotions to be treated gently, and your body to participate in joy.

📚 Sources discussed: Pirkei Avot (Ethics of the Fathers) 3:12; Rabbi Yishmael; Talmud, Shabbat (the oil lamp law story); Shmuel II (2 Samuel) — King David and Michal; a Baal Shem Tov story on joy and the body; Melachim (Kings) — Elisha and Elijah; the Torah’s account of Joshua’s devotion to Moses; the Rabban Gamliel–Rabbi Yehoshua Yom Kippur dispute; Hillel and Shammai and the three converts; the Kabbalistic concept of Chochmah and Binah as the source of the emotions.

▶️ YouTube: /rabbiheschelgreenberg 🎵 TikTok: /rabbi_greenberg 💼 LinkedIn: /rabbihgreenberg

In this class

  1. 0:00Why a rabbi's name can disappear from history — introducing Rabbi Yishmael
  2. 5:06The Mishna's three-level guide to respect: superior, equal, and below
  3. 9:14Holy foolishness: King David's dance before the Ark
  4. 16:48Learning by living with your teacher: Elisha, Joshua, and Moses
  5. 22:27How to treat those younger than you without becoming like them
  6. 33:02Greeting everyone with real joy: Shammai vs. Rabbi Yishmael
  7. 36:32The inner Mishna: mind, emotions, and the holiness of the body
  8. 42:35Q&A: Moses' sons, humility, and the cost of leadership

Part of the series Pirkei Avot (Ethics of the Fathers)