Torah vs. Wealth: True Leadership
About this class
Rabbi Greenberg teaches the Mishnah in which Rabbi Yosi ben Kisma, offered great wealth to move to another town, answers that he would live only in a place of Torah, since at death a person takes with him only Torah and good deeds. Rabbi Greenberg first notes that Torah study has value in itself and, when someone else can do another mitzvah, takes precedence over it.
Following the Abarbanel, he reads the journey as life itself: each person has a particular mission, and once it is found, one should not be drawn away from it. The Hebrew word for "met me" can also mean "affronted me." Rabbi Greenberg brings the Maharal's view that Rabbi Yosi did not greet the man first because he was absorbed in study, and the Rebbe's view that the man's offer was disrespectful, since leading with money implied that a rabbi serves for pay. The Maharal also explains that the community wanted a rabbi it could control, which leads Rabbi Greenberg to discuss leaders who look back to see what their followers want. A thought that arises only when there is personal gain may come from the wrong side, as in a story of Rabbi Nachum of Chernobyl.
He contrasts Rabbi Yosi's words with Balaam's similar statement about a house full of gold, and suggests the man was offering the freedom of a city outside harsh Roman control. Finally, he explains why Rabbi Yosi did not go spread Torah: the Rebbe's guidance was that one whose soul truly craves Torah should keep studying, while others should go out and teach.
- When someone else can perform another mitzvah, one may not interrupt Torah study for it; if no one else can, one must stop and help.
- Every person has a particular mission, and once it is clear one should not be distracted from it, however attractive the alternatives.
- Offering a rabbi money first implies he is in it for the money, and a community that controls its rabbi through salary or the power to fire him prevents him from truly leading.
- When a new option occurs to a person only once it holds something for himself, it may come from the evil inclination, as Rabbi Nachum of Chernobyl reasoned when he gave a large sum to one poor man.
- Balaam was faulted for a similar statement about gold because he really wanted the money, while Rabbi Yosi rejected it outright and spoke in obvious exaggeration.
- According to the Rebbe, one whose soul craves Torah so much that there is no question should keep studying, while others should go out to teach and help other Jews.
Explore the profound wisdom of Rabbi Yossi ben Kisma as he teaches the value of Torah over material wealth. This lesson delves into the challenges of modern rabbinic leadership, the importance of staying true to one’s mission, and the eternal value of Torah study. Discover why some choose a life dedicated to learning while others engage in outreach.
In this class
- 0:00Introduction: The Power of the Shofar
- 3:19Rabbi Yossi ben Kisma's Journey
- 6:58The Value of Torah Over Wealth
- 12:17Challenges in Modern Rabbinic Leadership
- 18:23Different Paths: Study vs. Outreach
- 25:47The Passion for Torah Learning
- 35:33Balancing Torah Study and Community Needs
- 42:14Conclusion: The Eternal Value of Torah