The Watchful Eye: God's Presence and Personal Accountability in Jewish Ethics
About this class
Rabbi Greenberg explains the closing words of the first mishnah of chapter 2 of Ethics of the Fathers: reflect on three things and you will not come to sin, know what is above you, an eye that sees, an ear that hears, and all your deeds written in a book. He presents the mishnah's four motivations for keeping mitzvos: the beauty of a mitzvah, the fact that it is God's will, its consequences, and, as a last resort, awareness that God is watching. He cites Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai's deathbed blessing that one's fear of heaven should equal one's fear of other people, and links the teaching to Rabbi Yehudah's division of the ten plagues into three groups, which showed that God exists, knows what happens, and holds everyone accountable.
Rabbi Greenberg argues that much wrongdoing today stems from a lack of respect for any higher authority. He notes that technology now makes it easy to imagine every word being seen, heard and recorded. God sees through the prism of Torah, with breadth, depth and length, and gives us the same abilities: to see the good in others through Torah, to hear others through prayer, and to write our book through acts of kindness. The Alter Rebbe read "know what is above you" as "know that what is above is from you," meaning God reciprocates our conduct. Another reading is that a person must know his history.
- The mishnah offers four motivations for mitzvos: their beauty, God's command, their consequences, and awareness that God is watching.
- Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai blessed his students that their fear of heaven should be like their fear of other people, since people refrain from wrongdoing when someone is watching.
- Rabbi Yehudah's grouping of the plagues taught that God exists, that He knows what happens, and that He holds everyone accountable.
- The eye, ear and book correspond to Torah, prayer and acts of kindness, through which people can see the good in others and become sensitive to their needs.
- The Alter Rebbe interpreted "know what is above you" to mean that what happens above depends on us, because God reciprocates our conduct.
- Another interpretation reads "above you" in terms of time, obligating a person to know and learn from Jewish history.
Discover how ancient wisdom from Pirkei Avot offers profound guidance for navigating our modern moral landscape. In this enlightening Torah discussion, we explore the final section of Chapter 2, Mishna 1, which addresses our awareness of divine presence as a foundation for ethical living. In this comprehensive Torah exploration, we’ll discover:
- The four progressive levels of motivation for observing mitzvot
- How awareness of God’s presence shapes our ethical choices
- The connection between personal accountability and moral behavior
- The parallel between the ten plagues of Passover and divine awareness
- How modern technology reflects ancient spiritual concepts
- Practical applications of these teachings in contemporary society
- The reciprocal relationship between human actions and divine response
This teaching explores the concluding part of Mishna 1, which states: “Apply your mind to three things and you will not come into the clutches of sin: know what there is above you - an eye that sees, an ear that hears, and all your deeds are written in a book.” We examine how this ancient wisdom provides a powerful framework for ethical decision-making and moral development.
💡 Essential Teachings: Four levels of motivation for mitzvot: aesthetic beauty, divine connection, consequences, and awareness of God’s presence The ten plagues of Egypt demonstrated three fundamental aspects of God: His existence, His awareness, and His accountability Modern technology gives us tangible ways to understand divine omniscience The decline in respect for authority contributes to moral challenges in society Torah provides a lens to see beyond the surface - seeing context, depth, and timelessness
🤔 Questions for Reflection and Discussion: How does your awareness of being “watched” affect your behavior? In what ways do you experience the “eye that sees, ear that hears” in your life? How can we cultivate greater awareness of the divine in our daily actions? What connections do you see between the Passover story and personal accountability? How might the principles of this Mishna help address moral challenges in modern society?
📖 Primary Sources: Pirkei Avot (Ethics of Our Fathers) Chapter 2, Mishna 1 Talmudic discussion on Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai’s deathbed teaching Story of the Kitzur (Rabbi Shlomo Ganzfried) and the wagon driver Connection to the Passover Haggadah’s discussion of the ten plagues
In this class
- 0:00Introduction and the Rebbe's Birthday
- 2:00Review of Previous Parts of the Mishna
- 7:00The Final Part: Three Things to Consider
- 9:00The Eye That Sees - Divine Awareness
- 15:00The Connection to Passover's Ten Plagues
- 21:00Modern Technology as a Reflection of Divine Awareness
- 24:00The Crisis of Moral Authority in Contemporary Society
- 29:00Seeing the World Through Torah's Lens
- 33:00The Reciprocal Relationship Between God and Humans
- 38:00Concluding Thoughts and Announcements