Skip to content
Video class January 15, 2025 46 min

The Paradox of Jewish Leadership: Why Great Leaders Don't Seek Power

About this class

Pirkei Avos 1:10

Rabbi Greenberg explains Shemaya's teaching in Ethics of the Fathers: love work, hate power (rabbanus), and do not become intimate with the ruling authority. He opens with the story of the crowds who left the High Priest to follow Shemaya and Avtalyon, sages loved for their humility and care for the people, and describes the turbulent era in which they lived. The rabbis valued physical labor; Abraham chose Canaan over lands of idle people because people who work are building a world that can then receive spiritual light.

Reading "love the work" together with "hate power," he teaches that society needs leaders, but a leader should love the work of helping others rather than the authority it brings. True leaders do not seek the role: Moses argued with God, and the Rebbe refused for a full year after his father-in-law's passing, accepting only when his wife urged him. Leadership drains a person, as the Talmud says of Joseph, and as with Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah's beard turning white. On a deeper level, the inner faculty of leadership is revealed only when others ask for it, as on Rosh Hashanah we ask God to be our King, and as our acceptance of Mashiach reveals his leadership.

A contemporary commentary reads the warning about rulers as a caution against joining secular revolutionary movements, citing the Jews who joined the Russian Revolution. Stories of the Rebbe, who said his purpose was to bend down to those in need, illustrate a leader who looks up to everyone.

  • The rabbis valued physical labor, and Abraham recognized Canaan as his destination because its people worked rather than sat idle.
  • Even a leader should love the work of serving others and not the power or status that comes with the position.
  • Great leaders such as Moses and the Rebbe resisted taking leadership until they had no choice.
  • Leadership takes a toll, as seen in Joseph dying first among his brothers and in Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah's beard turning white.
  • The deepest level of leadership is activated only when others ask for it, as on Rosh Hashanah we ask God to be our King.
  • The Rebbe told a rabbi who apologized for making him bend down to pick up a note that his whole purpose was to bend down to people in need.

Summary prepared from the class recording.

🌟 Discover timeless wisdom about authentic leadership from Ethics of Our Fathers

In this profound exploration of Jewish wisdom, we delve into a fundamental teaching that challenges modern notions of power and leadership. Through ancient insights that feel remarkably relevant today, we’ll uncover why true leaders often resist their calling, and why those who eagerly seek power may be least suited to wield it.

📚 In this enlightening Torah discussion, we’ll explore: • Why great Jewish leaders like Moses initially refused leadership • The crucial difference between loving work and loving power • How humility paradoxically makes better leaders • Real-world examples from both ancient and modern Jewish history • Practical applications for leadership in our own lives • The deeper spiritual dimensions of authentic leadership

This teaching is more relevant than ever in our age of viral influencers and instant celebrities. Whether you’re in a leadership position, aspiring to lead, or simply interested in Jewish wisdom, you’ll discover profound insights about power, responsibility, and authentic service.

💡 Essential Teachings:

  1. True leadership comes from service, not desire for power
  2. The paradox: Great leaders often resist leadership
  3. Leadership should focus on work and responsibility, not authority
  4. External validation shouldn’t be the motivation for leadership
  5. The spiritual root of authentic leadership

📖 Primary Sources:

  • Ethics of Our Fathers, Chapter 1, Mishna 10
  • Talmudic accounts of Moses’s reluctance to lead
  • Stories of the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s leadership
  • Biblical accounts of King David’s ascension

🤔 Questions for Reflection:

  1. How do you handle positions of authority in your life?
  2. What motivates your desire to lead or influence others?
  3. How can we apply these principles in modern organizational leadership?
  4. What’s the difference between leading from ego versus leading from service?

In this class

  1. 0:00Introduction to Ethics of Our Fathers Chapter 1
  2. 0:38Setting the Historical Context
  3. 1:14The Story of Shemaya and Avtalyon Begins
  4. 2:15The High Priest and the People's Choice
  5. 3:00Confrontation with the High Priest
  6. 4:12The Meaning Behind Their Names: Shemaya and Avtalyon
  7. 5:30Historical Background: Queen Shlomtzion's Era
  8. 6:45The Civil War and Roman Intervention
  9. 8:45Core Teaching: "Love Work"
  10. 10:15Abraham's Search for a Worthy Land
  11. 12:30The Value of Physical Labor in Judaism
  12. 14:20Balancing Torah Study with Work
  13. 15:40Moses as the Model of Reluctant Leadership
  14. 17:25The Power of Humility in Leadership
  15. 19:10Understanding True Authority
  16. 20:45The Role of Community in Leadership
  17. 23:55The Lubavitcher Rebbe's Example of Leadership
  18. 25:30The Year of Resistance to Leadership
  19. 27:15Leading Through Service, Not Power
  20. 29:40The Deeper Meaning of Leadership
  21. 31:20The Spiritual Dimensions of Authority
  22. 33:45King David's Path to Leadership
  23. 35:20Practical Applications for Modern Life
  24. 37:15Stories of True Leadership
  25. 39:30The Burden and Responsibility of Power
  26. 41:45The Nature of Public Service
  27. 43:20Warning Against Political Power
  28. 44:50Final Thoughts on Authentic Leadership
  29. 46:00Concluding Message: Simple Living, Complex Impact

Part of the series Pirkei Avot (Ethics of the Fathers)