Skip to content
Video class December 10, 2023 6 min

The Missing Moshiach

About this class

Rabbi Greenberg asks why Jews are so preoccupied with the famous Chanukah question: why eight nights, when the oil found was enough for the first night and the miracle lasted only seven? He reviews traditional answers, then argues that the obsession reflects a deeper question everyone asks, consciously or not: why are we still in exile? The Chanukah victory brought a rededicated Beis HaMikdash and independence from foreign rule, close to what the Rambam describes as the Messianic age, but no descendant of King David was appointed king. Without Mashiach the achievement degenerated, leading eventually to the Second Temple's destruction and a 2,000-year exile.

He explains that seven is the cycle of nature, a system with flaws, while eight transcends the system and repairs what is broken. Healing is the eighth blessing of the Amidah, linked to circumcision on the eighth day, and Mashiach's harp will have eight strings rather than King David's seven. Chanukah holds the tension between seven and eight, and the question expresses a desire for Redemption.

  • Traditional answers to the eight-nights question include the military victory, finding the cruse of oil, and dividing the oil into eight portions.
  • The Chanukah victory gave the Jews a purified Beis HaMikdash and freedom from foreign rule, but no descendant of King David was made king.
  • The Rambam makes clear that the Messianic age must be brought by Mashiach, so without him the Chanukah achievement eventually fell apart.
  • Seven represents the natural system with its flaws, while eight transcends the system and repairs its breaches.
  • Rabbi Greenberg says the legalistic question about Chanukah's eighth night expresses a deep desire for Redemption.

Summary prepared from the class recording.

Why we still await the Mashiach after the Chanukah miracle. The key that was missing 2000 years ago and what it means for today. The Obsession with the Chanukah Question 0:00 The Missing Moshiach After the Miracle 2:10 Exile as an Unhealed Breach 3:55 The Tension Between Seven and Eight 5:51

In this class

  1. 0:00The Obsession with the Chanukah Question
  2. 2:10The Missing Moshiach After the Miracle
  3. 3:55Exile as an Unhealed Breach
  4. 5:51The Tension Between Seven and Eight

Part of the series Jewish Holidays, Moshiach