Practice Makes Perfect - 5
About this class
In the fifth class of Practice Makes Perfect, Rabbi Greenberg surveys the ways the mitzvos are divided into categories. Positive commandments express God's immanence, His identification with the world, while prohibitions reflect His transcendence and let a person rebel against society in a Godly way. The two tablets show that commandments between people and God and those between people are equal; a person cannot truly love God while mistreating others, and social ethics alone will not last.
Statutes have no apparent reason, like the red heifer; testimonies commemorate events, like Passover, Shabbos, tefillin and mezuzah; and judgments are laws reason would dictate. Rabbi Greenberg explains that these build three supports of ethical behavior: respect for authority, inner spirituality and social consciousness, which together form a threefold cord.
Biblical law means the Torah's text together with the oral tradition, since the written Torah, like an outline, cannot be understood on its own, as with defining work on Shabbos. The Torah also obliges the rabbis to add safeguards and enactments, such as muktzah, Hillel's prozbul, the ban on polygamy, the kesubah, Chanukah, Shabbos candles and the sale of chametz. He then reviews the six orders of the Mishnah compiled by Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi and the Rambam's fourteen books. Finally, accepted customs become binding, as Simchas Torah shows, and the Talmud says God loves rabbinic mitzvos even more, since they show love that anticipates His wishes.
- Positive commandments reflect God's presence within the world, while prohibitions reflect His transcendence beyond it.
- The Ten Commandments were given on two equal tablets to show that duties toward God and toward other people cannot be separated.
- Statutes, testimonies and judgments develop respect for authority, inner spirituality and social consciousness, which together keep people ethical.
- The written Torah cannot be applied without the oral tradition, which defines terms such as work on Shabbos and murder.
- The Torah obliges the rabbis to enact safeguards and new institutions, such as Hillel's prozbul, Shabbos candles and the sale of chametz.
- Accepted positive customs, such as Simchas Torah, become binding, and they express love by anticipating what God wants.
Dive deep into the complex 613 mitzvot - God’s commandments in the Torah - and how they shape Jewish life. Introduction 00:00 The nature of mitzvot - commandments between God and man. Positive vs negative commandments. Man to God, Man to Man 02:20 The two tablets of the Ten Commandments - one tablet for commandments relating to man’s relationship with God, the second tablet for interpersonal laws. Statutes, Testimonies, Judgments 07:26 Categories of mitzvot - “Statutes” with no clear reason, “Testimonies” to commemorate events, “Judgments” that are logical laws. Six Orders - Agriculture, Festivals, Women, Damages, Holy Things, Purity 16:32 Maimonides’ 14 classifications of Jewish law. The Mishnah’s structure of organizing oral law into six orders. Biblical vs Rabbinic 47:15 The complex relationship between laws derived from the written Torah vs those enacted over time by rabbinic authority. Examples provided. Customs 55:14 How customs can attain status of law. Simchat Torah as an example of widely celebrated custom.