Pleasing People Pleases God: Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa’s Wisdo
About this class
In this Ethics of the Fathers class, Rabbi Greenberg teaches the Mishnah in which Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa says that one with whom people are pleased, God is pleased. He reads it as the culmination of Rabbi Chanina's previous teachings: fear of sin comes first, then wisdom, then deeds, and finally the effect on others. The two tablets, one for duties to God and one for duties to people, were carried side by side, and Yom Kippur does not atone for wrongs against others until they are set right.
The Mishnah calls God HaMakom, the One who fills all space, because God wants His presence revealed through how we treat others, while misconduct by a religious person causes chillul Hashem, a desecration that empties a place of God. As a teaching of piety beyond the letter of the law, the Mishnah asks that one help others pleasantly, even those without evident merit, and care for their spiritual needs as well.
- Rabbi Greenberg presents the Mishnah as the last of four steps in Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa's teachings: fear of sin, then Torah study, then deeds, and then pleasing other people.
- The two tablets, with duties to God on one and duties to people on the other, were carried side by side, and in one place the word for 'tablets' is spelled as a singular, showing that both form one message.
- The Mishnah uses the name HaMakom, the Omnipresent, because God wants His presence revealed in the world through our dealings with others; the Kotzker Rebbe taught that God is wherever one lets Him in.
- A religious person who mistreats others causes chillul Hashem, from a root meaning a void, driving awareness of God away, as in the Midrash about a man who wore tefillin all day and denied receiving a deposit.
- Since Pirkei Avos teaches conduct beyond the letter of the law, the Mishnah asks that one help others in a pleasant way, even those with no evident merit, and attend to their spiritual needs, such as items for mitzvos, not only their physical ones.
In this powerful class on Pirkei Avot, we explore one of the most practical and challenging teachings in Jewish ethics: “One with whom people are pleased, God is pleased.” Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa reveals that our relationships with other people are not separate from our relationship with God — they are deeply intertwined. This is not merely about being “nice.” It is about manifesting God’s presence in the world through how we treat others.
📚 In this transformative Torah exploration, we discover: • Why the two tablets of the Ten Commandments must be viewed as one unified message • The deep meaning of “HaMakom” (the Omnipresent) and how God’s presence becomes manifest through our interpersonal conduct • The difference between fulfilling the letter of the law and going “lifnim mishurat hadin” (beyond the letter of the law) • How pleasing the “spirit” of people includes caring for their spiritual needs, not just physical ones
This class builds directly on the previous two mishnayot (fear of sin before wisdom, and good deeds exceeding wisdom), showing the complete path: reverence for God → Torah study → action in the world → impact on other people. When we please others in a genuine, pleasant way, we fill the world with God’s presence rather than creating a vacuum through poor behavior.
📚 Primary Sources & References:
- Pirkei Avot 3:10 (and the two previous mishnayot)
- Exodus 20 & 34 — The Two Tablets and the spelling of “luchot”
- Psalms 111:10 & Proverbs — “The beginning of wisdom is the fear of God”
- Talmudic and Midrashic sources on Yom Kippur atonement requiring restitution to people
- Maimonides (Rambam) on lifnim mishurat hadin
- Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel’s “The Sabbath” (concept of sacred time and presence)
- Stories from the Baal Shem Tov, Menachem Mendel of Kotsk, and the Lubavitcher Rebbe
In this class
- 0:00Welcome & Introduction to Mishna 10
- 0:42Context from Previous Mishnayot (Fear of Sin & Good Deeds)
- 3:23The Ideal Daily Routine: Prayer, Torah Study, and Action
- 4:14Defining “Fear of Sin” — Reverence, Awe, and Trepidation
- 5:55The Two Tablets: Why Obligations to God and to People Are One
- 8:16Spelling of “Tablets” in the Torah — Plural Written, Singular Read
- 9:16Yom Kippur and the Requirement to Mend Relationships with People First
- 10:14HaMakom — The Omnipresent God and How His Presence Is Manifested
- 11:20Parallel to Comforting a Mourner (“HaMakom yenachem etchem”)
- 12:35The Kotsk Rebbe: “God Is Where You Let Him In”
- 14:20Gematria of HaMakom (= 186) and Its Deeper Meaning
- 16:02Impacting Others: The Danger of Chillul Hashem (Desecration of God’s Name)
- 17:14The Hidden Tzaddik Story (Baal Shem Tov) and Fulfilling One’s Mission
- 18:17Noah vs. Abraham: Why We Trace Our Lineage to Abraham
- 19:32How a “Religious” Person Can Create a Vacuum of God’s Presence
- 22:01The Shema: “You Shall Make God Beloved” Through Your Behavior
- 23:03The Midrash Story of the Man, the Money, and the Fillin-Wearing Jew
- 26:03Ethics of the Fathers vs. Law — What Is “Lifnim Mishurat Hadin”?
- 28:44“Pleasing” Means Doing It in a Pleasant Way (Not Begrudgingly)
- 29:43“Creatures” — Even Those Who Seem to Have No Obvious Qualities
- 31:12Pleasing the “Spirit” of People — Caring for Spiritual Needs Too
- 33:31Self-Sacrifice for an Enhanced Mitzvah (The Rebbe’s Etrog Story)
- 36:32General Spiritual Help (Tokhacha) and Final Q&A
- 39:15Sensitive Discussion: Scandals and Jewish Names in Business
- 41:04Closing Announcements & Upcoming Classes