Is It OK to Drink Alone?
About this class
Rabbi Greenberg asks how Noah, whom the Torah calls a perfect tzaddik, could become drunk after the flood and expose himself to indignity, leading him to curse one of his sons. Some commentaries suggest the flood changed the world's biology so that less wine made him drunk, but Rabbi Greenberg finds this unsatisfying, since the Torah includes only what teaches a lesson. Noah's drinking can be read two ways: as an escape from the anguish of seeing a devastated world and the daunting task of rebuilding it, or as a celebration of the miracle of his survival.
The simple test is whether a person drinks alone. Someone escaping wants solitude; someone celebrating wants others to join in. Had Noah been drinking with others, this would not have happened. The lesson is the importance of joy: we cannot wallow in destruction, and each day is a new beginning. Drinking within reason is not wrong in itself, but it should be done in joy and together with others, especially in a Hakhel year devoted to gathering Jews, as preparation for the joy of Mashiach.
- Rabbi Greenberg rejects the explanation that the flood changed Noah's tolerance for wine, since the Torah records only what teaches a lesson.
- Noah may have been drinking to escape the pain of a destroyed world, or to celebrate his miraculous survival.
- A person drinking to escape drinks alone, while a person celebrating wants others to share the joy.
- Noah was evidently drinking alone, since this would not have happened had others been with him.
- We must not wallow in destruction but meet each new beginning with joy, together with others, as preparation for Mashiach.
The lesson we learn from a tragic Biblical episode.