ETHICS OF OUR FATHERS – CHAPTER 4 MISHNA 1 Part II
About this class
Rabbi Greenberg continues Ben Zoma's teaching at the start of the fourth chapter of Pirkei Avos, comparing three definitions of a wise person found in the words of the sages: one who learns from every person, one who sees the future, and one who knows his place. He connects wisdom to chochmah, the soul's power to be fully receptive to what is beyond oneself without the ego putting up barriers; evaluation comes only afterward, at the level of binah. One who does not know his place, whether through a superiority or an inferiority complex, cannot learn from those who know more or less, while one who knows his place can learn from everyone and then look to the consequences of his actions and to the ultimate future.
He links the three definitions to world, year and soul, which Sefer Yetzirah names as the components of the universe and whose initials spell the Hebrew word for smoke; the Rebbe explains that the smoke at Sinai shows the Torah's purpose is to clear away what hides God in space, time and life. When elder Chassidim told the Rebbe "we need you," he replied, "I also need a Rebbe." A parable of a rich man and a poor wagon driver who each took the other's role teaches that people must use their own resources and talents.
On "Who is strong? One who subdues his inclination," Rabbi Greenberg explains that self-mastery surpasses even the courage the world glorifies, and that the text says "inclination," not "evil inclination," because one must also push past the limits of one's good nature. The inner battle is harder because the evil inclination disguises sins as mitzvos.
- Chochmah is the power to receive something higher than oneself without letting the ego filter or reject it; evaluation comes later, at the level of binah.
- Knowing one's place, without a superiority or inferiority complex, is what makes it possible to learn from everyone.
- The Rebbe explains that the smoke at Sinai alludes to space, time and soul, and that the Torah was given to clear away what conceals God in all three.
- A wealthy person should use his wealth to help others rather than take on roles suited to others, and the Rebbe held that someone with a talent such as music should use it to spread goodness.
- The Mishnah says "his inclination" rather than "his evil inclination" because a person must also go beyond the limits of his good nature, as the Alter Rebbe explains regarding Rabbi Chanina ben Teradion.
- The evil inclination often persuades a person that a wrong act is a mitzvah, which makes the inner battle harder than a physical one.