Can You Sing Your Way Out of a Rut?
About this class
Rabbi Greenberg explains whether song can bring atonement, starting from the Levites' singing in the Temple. Rashi reads the doubled "dedicated" in Numbers 8:16 as the Levites' two roles, carrying the Mishkan and singing. The Jerusalem Talmud says the song itself brought atonement, while the Babylonian Talmud treats it as an embellishment of the offering. Yet there was no singing for an individual's sin offering.
Rabbi Greenberg answers that atonement has two levels. The basic level requires facing what one did and repairing it, not escaping into inspiring melodies; the deeper level comes after repentance, when a refined person sees remaining flaws and needs spiritual elevation, where melody helps. The Babylonian Talmud, written for the darkness of exile, cannot rely on song, which would only cover what is underneath; the Jerusalem Talmud, a Talmud of clarity, addresses a person on a higher level. Today, which the Rebbe called the last generation of exile and first of redemption, we need both: honest, practical work on ourselves, and holy melodies, composed by holy people, as an independent spiritual experience.
- Rashi explains that the Levites had two roles, carrying the Mishkan and singing in the Temple.
- The Jerusalem Talmud says the Levites' song brought atonement, while the Babylonian Talmud sees it as an accessory to the offering.
- Basic atonement requires owning up to the wrong and repairing the damage, which music cannot replace.
- After repentance a person rises and recognizes finer flaws, and at that level melody helps bring further elevation.
- Because we live at the bridge between exile and redemption, holy melodies now have an independent role alongside down-to-earth self-improvement.
Can you sing your way out of a rut? A fascinating discussion on role of music and melody in addressing our shortcomings.